When family conflict isn't between parents
Updated: Oct 30
The forgotten side of family conflict
When we hear the words family dispute, we might imagine a separating couple trying to agree what happens next.
But family disagreements don't always look like that.
A new research project is drawing attention to the people who can sometimes be overlooked when we talk about family conflict.
The Forgotten 10% is a research project looking at private family law cases involving adults who aren't the child's parents. That includes grandparents, siblings, aunts, uncles, step-parents and other family members.
The project is being led by Lancaster University, in collaboration with the University of Bristol, Kinship and Families in Harmony, and is funded by the Nuffield Foundation.
It is looking at the experiences of children, families and professionals involved in these cases, and at whether the family justice system is properly responding to their needs.
I think it raises an important question:
What happens when family conflict doesn't fit the usual picture?

The “forgotten 10%”
Around 90% of private family law cases involve two parents.
The remaining 10% involve adults who aren't both parents of the child.
That might be a grandparent seeking to maintain a relationship with their grandchild.
It might be an aunt or uncle who has played an important role in a child's life.
It might be a step-parent.
Or it might involve other family members who have become closely involved in a child's care and wellbeing.
The research describes these cases as the “forgotten 10%” because they have historically received less attention in family justice research, policy and reform.
The research is ongoing, with the current project running through to 2027.
For me, what makes it particularly interesting is that it reminds us that families don't always fit neatly into the boxes we create for them.
Family conflict can be much wider than separation
Family mediation is often associated with separation and divorce.
And understandably so. Helping parents work through arrangements for their children or finances after a relationship ends is an important part of family mediation.
But family conflict can happen long before a separation, long after one, or without a separation at all.
Two adult siblings might disagree about how to care for an elderly parent.
Family members might have very different views about an inheritance.
Grandparents and parents might find themselves in conflict about children.
A blended family might struggle with boundaries and expectations.
Or something that happened many years ago might still be affecting relationships today.
These situations don't always make it into the public conversation about family mediation.
But they are still family problems.
When the issue isn't really the issue
One of the difficulties with family conflict is that the thing people are arguing about isn't always the whole story.
A disagreement about caring for a parent might also be about years of feeling that one sibling has done more than another.
An argument about an inheritance might carry old feelings of being treated unfairly.
A disagreement involving grandparents might be connected to difficulties between the adults that go much further back.
By the time people stop speaking, the original issue can become mixed up with everything that has happened before.
And when that happens, finding a way to have a constructive conversation can be difficult.
Sometimes the conversation needs some space
This is where I think mediation can have a role.
Mediation isn't about deciding who is right.
The mediator doesn't tell a family what they should do.
Instead, it provides an independent and structured space where people can talk about what matters to them, understand the other person's perspective and explore whether there is a way forward.
The decisions remain with the people involved.
That might lead to a practical agreement.
It might help people establish some boundaries around future communication.
Or it might simply help them understand what the other person needs, even if they don't agree on everything.
Mediation is voluntary and it isn't suitable for every situation. Where there are concerns about domestic abuse, coercion, safety or a significant imbalance of power, these need to be carefully considered before mediation can take place.
We are still learning about these families
That's why I think research such as The Forgotten 10% is important.
It asks us to look beyond the more familiar picture of family disputes and consider the experiences of people who can sometimes sit outside it.
The research is still underway, so it is too early to draw conclusions about what the final findings will tell us.
But the questions it is asking are important.
Who gets heard when family relationships break down?
What support do people need?
How can children be protected from adult conflict?
And are there ways of helping families resolve difficulties before relationships become even more entrenched?
These are questions worth asking.
Family mediation isn't just about separating couples
For me, the wider message is a simple one.
Sometimes the difficult conversation is between two parents.
Sometimes it is between brothers and sisters.
Sometimes it is between generations.
And sometimes there are several relationships involved at once.
The people involved may still have to see each other for years to come.
There may be children, grandchildren, elderly parents, family occasions or shared responsibilities that keep them connected.
That can make resolving the disagreement particularly important.
Not necessarily because everyone needs to become close again.
But because finding a way to manage the relationship differently can sometimes make life easier for everyone involved.
You don't have to know the answer before you start
When family relationships become difficult, it is easy to feel that you need to have everything worked out before you start talking.
You don't.
Sometimes the first step is simply having somewhere to talk.
To explain what matters to you.
To listen to what matters to someone else.
And to explore what might be possible from here.
Mediation won't be right for every family or every situation.
But where people are able and willing to have a conversation, it can sometimes provide the space needed to make that conversation possible.
The Forgotten 10% research is a reminder that family conflict comes in many different forms.
And perhaps the more we recognise that, the more we can think about how families can be supported when relationships become difficult.
Because sometimes the most important conversation isn't about who is right.
It's about finding a way forward.
Further reading
If you'd like to learn more about this research project, visit The Forgotten 10%”or Lancaster University
Could mediation help?
If something in your family has become difficult to talk about, you don't have to have all the answers before taking the first step. At New Moon Mediation, I help families have difficult conversations in a calm, structured and confidential setting, whether the issue involves separation, siblings, grandparents or other family relationships. If you'd like to explore whether mediation could help, find out more about family mediation or get in touch for an initial conversation.
Enjoyed this article?
Receive occasional insights on separation, family relationships and finding a positive way forward, straight to your inbox.




Comments