top of page

Who gets the dog when a relationship ends?

hagansteven
Oct 19
6 min read

Updated: Oct 30

When a relationship ends, there are difficult decisions to make. Where will each person live? How will finances and property be divided? If there are children, how will arrangements work so they can maintain a relationship with both parents?


But what about the family dog?

For many couples, a dog is far more than a pet. It is part of the family. Both partners may have cared for it, taken it for walks and built a close bond with it. For children, the dog may be a familiar source of comfort at a time when much of their world is changing.


When a relationship ends, those attachments don't simply disappear.


So what happens when two people who still love the same dog can no longer agree on what is best for it? Who gets the dog?


A golden retriever sits between two adults turned away from each other at home, illustrating the emotional challenges of deciding who keeps the family dog after separation.
When a relationship ends, deciding who keeps the family dog can be one of the most emotional decisions to make.

Who gets the dog, is not just about who bought the dog


One person may have bought the dog, but that doesn't necessarily reflect the bond each partner has developed with it.


Perhaps one person has always done the morning walks, while the other has been responsible for feeding and veterinary appointments. Perhaps one works from home and spends much of the day with the dog, while the other has always looked forward to coming home to it.


Both may feel that the dog is an important part of their life. Both may believe they can offer it a good home.


These feelings can make discussions difficult. What starts as a practical question can quickly become an argument about fairness, past contributions or who deserves to keep the pet.


Sometimes, the dog becomes another issue over which neither person is prepared to compromise.


Recognising how much the dog matters to each person can be an important first step towards finding a way forward.


What is the legal position?


In England and Wales, pets are generally treated as property under the law, rather than in the same way as children. There is no equivalent of a child arrangements order that determines when a dog should live with each person.


If ownership is disputed, relevant evidence may include who acquired the dog, any agreement between the parties, registration records and who has been responsible for its care and costs. The legal position will depend on the circumstances, including whether the dispute arises within divorce proceedings or between unmarried partners.



Understanding the legal position doesn't necessarily resolve the emotional or practical questions, however. Even where ownership is clear, there may still be difficult conversations about the dog's future, the children's relationship with it and how responsibilities will be managed.


If ownership is contested, independent legal advice can help clarify your options.


Should you share the dog after separation?


Sharing care might seem like the fairest solution. Both people retain a relationship with the dog, and neither feels they have lost something important.


But an arrangement that feels fair to the adults isn't necessarily the best arrangement for the dog.


Dogs have individual needs. Their age, health, temperament, established routines and ability to adapt all matter when considering whether moving between two homes would work.


Some dogs may adapt well to spending time in different homes. Others may find repeated changes unsettling. If there are concerns about how a proposed arrangement might affect your dog, a vet or suitably qualified animal behaviour professional can offer guidance.


There are practical questions to consider, too:


  • How often would the dog move between homes?

  • Are both homes suitable for the dog's needs?

  • Who will pay for food, insurance and veterinary treatment?

  • How will holidays, work commitments and unexpected changes be managed?

  • Who will make decisions about the dog's care?

  • What happens if one person's circumstances change?


An arrangement that looks straightforward on paper can become difficult if expectations are not clear.


Equally, deciding that one person will provide the dog's main home doesn't mean the other person's attachment should be dismissed.


The aim is to find an arrangement that is practical, sustainable and appropriate for the dog, rather than simply dividing time equally between two people.


What about the children?


When children are involved, the family dog can take on an even greater significance.


Children may already be adjusting to a new home, changes in their routines or spending time away from one parent. Their dog may be one of the few familiar things that makes them feel secure.


They may worry about who will look after the dog, whether they will still see it and what will happen when they stay with the other parent.


These concerns deserve to be heard.


Could arrangements for the dog fit alongside the children's existing routines?
Would seeing the dog when staying with one parent help them feel settled?
Or would moving the dog between homes create additional complications?

There is no single answer for every family.


It is also important not to make children responsible for deciding who keeps the dog or leave them feeling that they must choose between their parents. Adults need to take responsibility for the decision, while considering the children's feelings and the dog's welfare. You can read more about supporting children through family change in my article on putting children first during separation.


Sometimes, what works best for the children may not be the same as what works best for the dog. Acknowledging that possibility can help parents explore their options more openly.


When agreement feels impossible


When emotions are running high, it can be difficult to separate practical decisions from the hurt associated with the end of a relationship.


One person may feel they are being asked to give up a member of their family. The other may feel their own attachment and contribution are being overlooked.


Repeating the same arguments rarely moves things forward. When communication has broken down, there are ways to approach difficult conversations more constructively. My article on co-parenting when communication has broken down explores some of these challenges.


It can help to step back and consider what matters most to each person.


Is it spending time with the dog?

Knowing it is being well cared for?

Maintaining the children's relationship with it?

Or making sure that responsibilities and costs are shared fairly?


Once these concerns are understood, different possibilities may emerge.


Perhaps one person provides the dog's main home while the other remains involved in an agreed way. Perhaps sharing care is realistic, provided it suits the dog and both people can manage the arrangements. Or perhaps a different solution is needed.


There is no guarantee that both people will get everything they want. But looking beyond the question of who should win can open up a more constructive conversation about what happens next.


Could mediation help?


Family mediation is often associated with arrangements for children, finances and property. Yet separation can raise many other issues that people find difficult to resolve between themselves.


Where disagreement about a pet forms part of a wider separation, mediation may provide an opportunity to discuss the concerns, explore practical options and consider possible arrangements.


A mediator does not decide who should keep the dog or impose a solution. Instead, the aim is to help the people involved have a constructive conversation and make their own decisions. You can also read my step-by-step guide to how family mediation works.


Mediation may be particularly useful when pet arrangements overlap with other issues, such as where the children will live, changes to the family home or the division of responsibilities.


It will not be suitable for every situation, and an agreement cannot be guaranteed. Suitability must be considered carefully, particularly where there are concerns about safety, coercion or an imbalance of power.


Where mediation is appropriate, however, a supported conversation may help people move beyond an entrenched disagreement and find a way forward.


Finding a way forward


When a relationship ends, it can be tempting to divide everything into two: yours and mine, your responsibilities and mine, your future and mine.


But family life rarely fits neatly into those categories.


A much-loved dog may continue to matter to both people long after the relationship has ended. Finding a way forward means acknowledging those feelings while being realistic about what will work for the people involved and, most importantly, the animal.


There may not be a perfect solution. There may, however, be one that is practical, considered and fair.


And sometimes, finding it begins with a conversation that neither person has found easy to start.


At New Moon Mediation, I help separating couples have constructive conversations about the issues that matter to them. If you are struggling to agree on arrangements following separation, mediation may offer a way to explore your options.


Enjoyed this article?


Receive occasional insights on separation, family relationships and finding a positive way forward, straight to your inbox.



Comments


bottom of page